Independent agency · Fort Myers, Florida
Independence. Integrity. Trust
Our family-owned agency has been helping to protect families and businesses in Lee County since 1982.
- 1982Founded by Terry Keith
- 30+Carriers we can shop
- Lee CountyFamily owned and operated
What we cover
Coverage for the things you have worked for
-
Auto
The right auto insurance isn’t just about your car, it’s about protecting you and the people in it.
Auto insurance -
Home
With homeowners insurance, you can rebuild or replace your home (and your stuff) after a disaster.
Home insurance -
Specialty
Do you have a boat, RV, ATV, or other toys? You need special coverage, and don’t forget umbrella insurance!
Specialty insurance -
Flood
Your homeowners policy doesn’t cover flooding, but don’t worry: We have many flood insurance options.
Flood insurance -
Commercial
From small businesses to big corporations, we help companies of all kinds find commercial insurance.
Commercial insurance
Our story
Deep roots in Lee County
“A 50-cent Bic pen, a sport coat, and a dream.”
Terry Keith started his insurance agency four decades ago with “a 50-cent Bic pen, a sport coat, and a dream.” Today, it’s still a family business. Following the example set by his father, Ian Keith is leading Keith Insurance with the same dedication to service and community. (You’ll still see Terry around the office, too.)
The difference
Why choose an independent agent?
Unlike many other agents, we aren’t locked into working with one insurance company. We can shop with over 30 different carriers to help you find coverage at the right price for auto insurance, home insurance, condo insurance, commercial insurance, and business insurance. (You didn’t really want to do all that shopping on your own, did you?)
- One agency, many carriers. We put your situation in front of the companies most likely to want it, and bring the options back to you.
- We re-shop when the market moves. Florida’s property market changes quickly. A policy that was right two years ago may not be the right one today.
- We work for you. If what you already have is the better deal, that is what we will tell you.
Our promise
Our commitment to you
We can’t promise that we’ll make insurance fun, but we will make it as easy and stress-free as possible. And after you have your policy, our work is only beginning: as your local insurance agent, we take pride in returning all calls in a timely fashion, with professional advice. It’s been the Keith Insurance way for 40 years.
Already a client?
Find out more about our carriers
Make a payment, file a claim, request proof of insurance or ask for a policy change. Our Customers page lists every carrier we work with, along with their payment and claims contacts.
Get in touch
Let Keith Insurance help you protect what’s most important.
Call the office for a complimentary insurance review. You will reach a person in Fort Myers, not a call centre, and we will shop more than thirty carriers on your behalf.